Report released at Munich Security Conference accuses Trump administration of dismantling global order.
Report’s Purpose and Symbolic Title
European elites are defending against Donald Trump by releasing a report at the Munich Security Conference, framing the current America as a source of global destruction. The report’s title, “W rozbiórce” (“In Demolition”), ironically references construction jargon, featuring a disintegrating Republican elephant symbol to imply Trump’s policies are fracturing his party and the international order.
Demolition Men vs. Reformists
The report contrasts “bulldozer policy” advocates (“Demolition Men”) driven by “desire for destruction” from frustration with existing structures, with reformists aiming to overhaul the global order. The former’s narrative is presented as rooted in societal dissatisfaction, despite the report’s counter-arguments. Surveys show majority pessimism in Europe about future generations’ prospects under current governments.
Global Pessimism and Optimism
Research cited in the report reveals widespread pessimism in Europe (60% in France believe future generations will fare worse) and high optimism in China (80% believe in a better future), attributed to China’s official narrative of “national rejuvenation.” Notably, China and BRICS nations were excluded from questions about helplessness.
Historical Parallels and Shift
The report references Dean Acheson’s memoir “Present at the Creation” to contrast with the current era of “Present at the Destruction.” It details Trump’s withdrawal from international organizations and disregard for international law, contrasting past administrations’ legal arguments with Trump’s reliance on “personal morality.”
Legal and Moral Concerns
Trump’s administration is criticized for ignoring international law, citing actions like the abduction of Nicolás Maduro and bombing of Iranian nuclear facilities. The report expresses greater concern over an order lacking standards than selective enforcement, highlighting Trump’s claim that only his “own morality” constrains him.
Clash of Visions
European elites fear Trump’s abandonment of the “leader of the free world” role, contrasting with Joe Biden’s moralistic defense of Ukraine. The report warns the West is shifting toward an “illiberal-nationalist” project emphasizing cultural, ethnic, and religious criteria, challenging the exhausted liberal universalism.