National Prosecutor’s Office Launches Investigation Into Judge Zbigniew Kapiński
The National Prosecutor’s Office has initiated an investigation into Supreme Court Judge Zbigniew Kapiński, citing a reasonable suspicion of abuse of power regarding his administrative orders...
The National Prosecutor’s Office has initiated an investigation into Supreme Court Judge Zbigniew Kapiński, citing a reasonable suspicion of abuse of power regarding his administrative orders concerning judge exclusions.
Table Of Content
Investigation into Administrative Conduct
The investigation was opened on Monday by a specialized team of prosecutors tasked with addressing the legal consequences of rulings issued by judges appointed via the National Council of the Judiciary (KRS) after 2017. The probe focuses on specific orders issued by Zbigniew Kapiński between 2024 and 2026, during his tenure as head of the Supreme Court’s Criminal Chamber.
The National Prosecutor’s Office alleges that these orders obstructed the legal process for excluding judges whose impartiality was questioned under Article 41 § 1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Officials claim these actions effectively eliminated the mechanism for challenging judges, thereby violating the right to a fair trial before an independent and impartial court.
Internal Conflicts Over Judicial Status
In February, reports highlighted that parties appearing before the Supreme Court frequently sought to exclude judges appointed under the new KRS framework. A recurring legal issue arose as these exclusion requests were often reviewed by other judges with the same appointment status, creating a de facto conflict of interest.
In November of last year, Kapiński issued an order prohibiting the registration of motions filed by the prosecution to exclude these judges. An earlier order from May 2024 had mandated that such motions be routed exclusively through him and the then-First President of the Supreme Court, Małgorzata Manowska.
Legal Basis for the Probe
The investigation follows a notification filed by a group of Supreme Court judges who argued that Kapiński’s orders prevented proper legal review of impartiality challenges. Prosecutors have since interviewed witnesses and reviewed documentation regarding the challenged orders and their subsequent impact on judicial proceedings.
The collected evidence led to a reasonable suspicion of an offense under Article 231 § 1 of the Penal Code, which pertains to the abuse of power by a public official.
Kapiński’s Defense
Addressing the allegations on television, Kapiński stated that he takes full responsibility for his actions. He argued that the orders were necessary to prevent the stacking of frivolous motions intended to delay proceedings for years, asserting that he only restricted motions based solely on the judge’s appointment method rather than other objective evidence of bias.
Zbigniew Kapiński, who served as a judge at the Court of Appeal in Warsaw since 2001, was appointed to the Supreme Court in 2022 and became head of its Criminal Chamber in 2023. In May, President Karol Nawrocki appointed him as First President of the Supreme Court.


